Comparative evaluation of two hypofractionated radiotherapy regimens for painful bone metastases.

AIMS AND BACKGROUND: In 75% of the patients with bone metastases (BM) pain is the dominant symptom. Radiotherapy (XRT) plays a major role in the palliation of pain in patients with BM. Several schedules of short and long fractionation XRT are used in clinical practice, with hypofractionated treatments being even more attractive for practical reasons. A considerable body of evidence supports the clinical use of short schedules and single-dose XRT. We retrospectively evaluated the efficacy of two short fractionated schedules of 8 Gy as a single dose and 20 Gy in 5 fractions in relieving pain in patients with multiple uncomplicated BM. METHOD: From January to December 2001, 130 patients with 146 painful BM were treated with palliative localized XRT. There were 42 males and 88 females with a median age of 58 years (range 28-84). The commonest sites of treatment were the spine (59.6%) and pelvis (14.4%). The primary endpoint was clinically significant pain relief in the first six months of follow-up evaluated with the IAEA (International Atomic Energy Agency) pain measurement score measuring pain severity and pain frequency. Analgesic use was also recorded before and after treatment as drug frequency and drug severity. Patients with painful BM from any primary tumor site were irradiated. Treatment schedules consisted of a course of XRT with 4 Gy/fraction/day (total dose: 20 Gy/5 fractions) (group A, 59 lesions) or with a single dose of 8 Gy (group B, 87 lesions). RESULTS: There was no significant difference in complete response (CR) rates between treatment schedules: complete pain relief was achieved in 17/59 lesions (29%) in the fractionated group and in 29/87 lesions (33%) in the single-dose group. Also the overall response (complete + partial) was similar: 35/59 lesions (60%) in group A and 60/87 (69%) in group B. The minimum, maximum and median follow-up was 3, 23, and 9 months, respectively, for group A and 3, 20, and 11 months for group B. The actuarial median duration of pain relief was similar: 4.5 months in group A and 4 months in group B. No particular side effects were recorded in either group. CONCLUSIONS: There were no differences between the two fractionation schedules used in our study with regard to pain relief and use of analgesics. Palliation of pain was obtained in approximately two thirds of patients with both schedules, providing further evidence of the similar efficacy between single and multiple fractions. With regard to pain response these data justify a recommendation for the use of a more simple and convenient 8 Gy single fraction for the palliation of uncomplicated BM.

Cryohypophysectomy for the relief of pain in malignant disease.

Fifty consecutive patients with metastatic carcinoma who underwent cryohypophysectomy were studied. Of these, 26 had breast cancer, 19 had prostatic cancer, one had malignant melanoma, one had cancer of the kidney, and three had metastatic adenocarcinoma from an unknown primary tumour. After cryohypophysectomy, excellent pain relief was obtained in 48% of patients, good or acceptable pain relief was obtained in 40%, and poor or no relief in 12%. Two patients died: one of aspiration pneumonia and one of an unknown cerebral cause. Sixteen patients developed diabetes insipidus, of whom three required therapy with vasopressin; eight patients developed a cerebrospinal fluid leak, two of whom required surgical repair; and four patients developed meningitis, which resolved in three after antibiotic therapy. Results are compared with those from other published reports. pain relief from cryohypophysectomy is surmised to be due to the production of endorphins, but no proof of this is available.

Centro-median thalamotomy for central pain following stroke --its effectiveness and limits

Centro-median thalamotomy was performed on 18 patients with central pain caused by cerebrovascular disease. Fourteen were males and four were females. Clinical diagnoses were thalamic pain in 17 cases including cheiro-orale syndrome in one case and phantom limb pain in one case. CT scans were performed on six recent cases. Four cases had a small low density sera in the thalamus. The other two cases had no remarkable findings. The target was 7.5-11.0 nm posterior to the middle point of the intercommissural line, 1.0 mm below-2.0 mm above that line and 5.5-10.0 mm from the midline. Unilateral lesion was made on 15 cases. Postoperatively, five cases had almost completely relief of pain and four cases had partial improvement. The duration of pain relief was, however, less than two months in four cases, and between three and seven months in four cases. One case had a pain free period for seven months. But, then, severe dysesthesia appeared. Six cases had no pain relief by unilateral lesion. Two cases had no pain relief by bilateral lesions. In the remaining case, unilateral lesion was effective for six months. Then lesion of opposite side was made, but the result was unsatisfactory. The durations from the onset of apoplectic attack to the occurrence of pain were between four months and three years in ten effective cases, and within three months in six among eight failed cases. Many surgical and medical treatments have been attempted for central pain. However, ideal method is still not appeared. Centro-median thalamotomy was effective for 56% of the patients with central pain. But in most of the cases, the duration of pain relief is about a half year at the longest. And may be, this is the limit of effectiveness of centro-median thalamotomy for central pain.

Radiation therapy in bone metastases from lung cancer

The record of 73 patients with 153 sites of bone metastases from a lung cancer treated by radiation have been reviewed to evaluate the effectiveness of pain relief. Radiation therapy for bone metastases was found to be very effective. Sufficient symptomatic improvement was achieved in 94% of all patients, while 63% obtained almost complete pain relief that was sustained until death. Onset of a symptomatic response to radiotherapy was within less than 20 Gy in total dose in more than 80% of all patients. There were no significant differences in the frequency of pain relief among the various histological types of primary lung tumors.

Interpleural administration of bupivacaine for postoperative analgesia after thoracotomy in patients with patent ductus arteriosus.

Interpleural analgesia for postoperative pain with bupivacaine 0.25%, 0.375% and 0.5% at dosage of 1.5 mg/kg was evaluated in three randomized groups (A, B and C) of 22 children having triple ligation for patent ductus arteriosus (PDA). Complete pain relief was obtained within 30 min irrespective of the concentration of bupivacaine. The duration of pain relief significantly varied with the concentrations of the drug used, respectively 5.02 +/- 0.4 h, 6.88 +/- 0.7 h and 8.24 +/- 1.08 h (mean +/- SD) for 0.25%, 0.375% and 0.5% bupivacaine (p less than 0.05). No side effects were observed and no other supplemented narcotics were given. We concluded that 0.5% bupivacaine at the dose of 1.5 mg/kg was effective in postoperative pain relief after thoracotomy in patients undergoing PDA ligation surgery.

A preliminary list to identify attitudes toward different conditions for discussing possible termination or refusal of medical treatment except for pain relief.

Effective communication about decisions concerning termination or refusal of medical treatment except for pain relief necessitates clarifying the attitudes of those in the decision-making process. Effective communication increases the likelihood that a patient's advance directives are implemented and decreases the likelihood of litigation. Psychotherapists, counselors, chaplains, etc. can be facilitators of effective communication. This study generated a list for use in discussion by asking persons who cared for individuals with terminal illnesses, critical injuries or elderly people what conditions seemed appropriate for termination or refusal of medical treatment except for pain relief. The 182 out of 204 individuals who contributed conditions showed clear agreement on terminal illnesses, brain disorders, dependence on machines for life, and other irreversible deterioration or severe loss of quality of life, lack of suitable treatment, patient's wish, and concern about the effect of the patient's condition on others. Some specified further qualifications, such as at what point during a terminal illness termination or refusal was appropriate. The list with notes could be appended to a Living Will or a Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care. The notes should be updated periodically. Through use and research, the list also can be refined further.

Patient attitudes regarding pca and associated costs.

PURPOSE: To determine patients' knowledge and attitudes towards patient-controlled analgesia (PCA) costs through the use of our acute pain service quality assurance (QA) programme. METHODS: Quality Assurance questionnaires were distributed to all patients receiving PCA opioids for > 12 hr. Patients were asked to note the presence of side effects (nausea/vomiting, pruritus, urinary retention), to indicate their satisfaction with regard to their pain relief, follow-up assessments, treatment of side effects, and to recall the previous method of pain relief and their satisfaction with it. Patients were also asked to estimate the total cost of PCA (0-$50, $50-100, $100-200, > $200), and what amount if any they would be willing to pay (0-$50, $50-100, $100-200, > $200). Results obtained over a recent four month period were reviewed. RESULTS: One hundred and thirty-three questionnaires were distributed and 103 (77%) were returned. The percentage of patients rating their satisfaction as very good or excellent was 86% for pain relief, 96% for follow-up, 71% for side effect treatment, but only 43% for their previous surgical pain relief (P < 0.001). The distribution of cost estimates was 10% $50-100, 37% $100-200 and 53% > $200 with 60% willing to pay a portion of this cost. Those willing to pay were more likely to have had very good or excellent pain relief (94% vs 71%, P < 0.05) and treatment of side effects (71% vs 48%, P < 0.05) than those not willing to pay. CONCLUSIONS: Patients continue to be highly satisfied with PCA therapy and are aware of the costs involved. A majority of patients were willing to pay to obtain this service if necessary. Patients who had poorer pain relief and less efficacious treatment of their side effects were less willing to pay.

Postoperative titration of intravenous morphine in the elderly patient.

BACKGROUND: Intravenous morphine titration is used to obtain rapid and complete postoperative pain relief. Whether this titration can be safely administered in the elderly patients remains a matter for debate. METHODS: Intravenous morphine titration was administered as a bolus of 2 (body weight < or = 60 kg) or 3 (body weight > 60 kg) mg. The interval between each bolus was 5 min. There was no limitation in the number of boluses given until pain relief or severe adverse effect occurred. The visual analog scale threshold required to administer morphine was 30 mm, and pain relief was defined as a visual analog scale score of 30 mm or less. Patients were divided into two groups: young and elderly (age > or = 70 yr) patients. Data were expressed as mean +/- SD. RESULTS: Eight hundred seventy-five patients (83%) were young and 175 patients (17%) were elderly. At the end of morphine titration, the visual analog scale score and the number of patients with pain relief were not significantly different between groups. The total dose of morphine per kilograms of body weight administered was not significantly different between groups (0.15 +/- 0.10 vs. 0.14 +/- 0.09 mg/kg, not significant). No significant differences were observed in the incidence of morphine-related adverse effects (13 vs. 14%, not significant), the number of sedated patients (60 vs. 60%, not significant), and the number of patients whose titration had to be stopped (2 vs. 2%, not significant). CONCLUSION: Intravenous morphine titration can be safely administered to elderly patients. Because titration is adapted to individual pain, the same protocol can be applied to young and elderly patients.

Temporary external pedicular fixation versus definitive bony fusion: a prospective comparative study on pain relief and function.

Temporary external pedicular fixation is used as a prognostic instrument when treating degenerative conditions with spinal fusion. We studied the validity of the method and whether a functional test could improve the prognostic value of such fixation. Twenty-six patients with long-standing lumbar pain had an external temporary fixation. Pain levels were registered before fixation on a visual analogue scale at rest, as a mean for the previous week, and at seven different standardized activities. Walking capacity and walking speed for a standardized distance were also measured. Identical evaluations were then repeated during the external fixation and 1 year after definitive fusion. Based on the outcome of the temporary fixation, 20 patients were recommended for definitive surgical fusion. In six cases, the option of fusion surgery was rejected due to an unfavourable pain response or insufficient pain relief during the test fixation period, and this group was not further followed within the study. One year after surgery, 14 of 20 patients reported a good outcome. Solid bony fusion assessed by conventional radiography was seen in 19 patients. One patient with a poor clinical outcome had a pseudarthrosis. The mean values for pain level at rest, during last week and at the seven different activities in the functional test tended to decrease after fusion compared to the situation with temporary external fixation. In no activity did the external fixator overestimate the mean positive pain-relieving effect after definitive fusion. The walking capacity significantly increased, while the walking speed did not alter at the three different measurements. We conclude that with a good outcome ratio of 14 patients out of 19 having a solid fusion, the external frame improved patient selection and can be used as a valid prognostic instrument. The pain relief and function after definitive fusion can not be quantified by the external fixation, probably due to the fact that the stabilisation with an external frame is partial. The value of the functional test design presented is moderate, and an outcome evaluation comprising pain relief at rest and mean pain level during a week in fixation seems adequate.

Dorsal root entry zone lesions (Nashold's procedure) for pain relief following brachial plexus avulsion.

Brachial plexus avulsion is an important cause of severe intractable pain, particularly in young motor cyclists. The pain usually develops soon after the injury. In a minority of cases severe pain persists and is refractory to management. Nineteen patients are reviewed in whom dorsal root entry zone lesions have been produced for pain relief. The operative technique is described. Early post-operative motor or sensory disturbance in the ipsilateral leg have been temporary side effects, with mild persisting deficits in a minority. Sixteen cases have had significant persisting pain relief. The maximum follow-up period is 2 1/2 years.